Skip to main content

First Assignment

Three Key Ideas discussed in this text:

1) The definition of community provided clears a lot of things up for me. At first I was struggling to find a comprehensive definition of community, but there always seemed to be exceptions. Having two separate definitions (spatial/institutional and identity base) really helps my understanding of what this class addresses. 

2) I was struck by the assertion that most community based public works seek to create a community consciousness. The author described this action as paternal. I think so much charity is done out of this mind set. That the paternalism is patronizing. I see that in myself when I go to offer help, that I have something that I think someone else needs. I have to step back and see whether or not they might actually want it. I hope in this class we address how socially responsible work can engage communities without a colonial approach.

3) I find it fascinating that in many of the projects described the person who is “the artist” is not practicing traditional art. Their major contributions to their projects are leadership and knowledge, and that the art produced does not belong to them. Are social workers artists as well?


Three questions



1) I am a little confused still with the part about representational dynamic of community politics. The two definitions seem so definitive. The descriptions also seem critical, like either the person representing a group is a martyr or a user. Both seem manipulative. Are there other ways of defining the ways that groups gain representation?

2) In the reading a politically coherent community is described as forming in a response to a collective mode of oppression. Is that the only way a politically coherent community can be formed? I think I am missing what it means to be politically coherent. For example I think that an environmental conservation community could be formed due to precautionary measures. Ansel Adams wasn’t fighting global warming when he advocated for national parks, he was just trying to protect areas of wilderness. Can a politically coherent community be precautionary?


3) What is a moral economy of capitalism? There is a really long sentence with very complex words talking about conservative arguments and  liberal reform. Honestly I get scared when ever politics begin to play a part in doing good because politics are connected to larger immovable machines. When doing good becomes political I see it shut down under the weight of competing parties.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rachel Tibbetts - What a Riot

Schutzman starts off this reflection with an excerpt from the play she created. The opening lines serve to give recognition and context to the subject matter by immediately dedicating the show to Rosa Parks. This is an extremely effective strategy to introduce the tone and subject matter of the piece. The addition of Claudette at the end was the “icing on the cake” to the introductory excerpt. Raising questions and therefore instantly opening up a dialogue. Schutzman approached the students by asking questions while also letting them choose the person/people they wanted to learn about and also depict in the play. I think entering a school with something to teach is the idealistic approach to interacting with students; when students are in class they are expecting to be taught and ask questions. This is the exact approach Shutzman used. This allowed her to familiarize herself with the student community and find their interests, question...
Post a Comment
Read more

Katharine Means What a Riot! Response

In 2005 Mady Shutzman was invited by CalArts CAP to write a play for the teenage participants Plaza de la Raza arts center in East Los Angeles to perform. At first I was intrigued by this, as my limited knowledge of Boal and Theatre of the Oppressed techniques has been around the participatory games, activities, and techniques used to build community. I know some about Forum and Legislative Theatre, but had little conception of what a TO play would look like. Shutzman's piece, UPSET! , was modeled using Boal's Joker System. There is a character called the Joker who probes the characters and audience during the play with the "ultimate goal to raise questions, offer multiple points of view, and encourage dialogue". Shutzman used this form as a "means to incorporate the teens curiosity, dismay, outrage, confusion, fear, and inspiration in relation to the subject matter of the play within the play." The teens decided upon Rodney King and Claudette Colvin (a youn...
Post a Comment
Read more