Skip to main content

First Assignment

Three Key Ideas discussed in this text:

1) The definition of community provided clears a lot of things up for me. At first I was struggling to find a comprehensive definition of community, but there always seemed to be exceptions. Having two separate definitions (spatial/institutional and identity base) really helps my understanding of what this class addresses. 

2) I was struck by the assertion that most community based public works seek to create a community consciousness. The author described this action as paternal. I think so much charity is done out of this mind set. That the paternalism is patronizing. I see that in myself when I go to offer help, that I have something that I think someone else needs. I have to step back and see whether or not they might actually want it. I hope in this class we address how socially responsible work can engage communities without a colonial approach.

3) I find it fascinating that in many of the projects described the person who is “the artist” is not practicing traditional art. Their major contributions to their projects are leadership and knowledge, and that the art produced does not belong to them. Are social workers artists as well?


Three questions



1) I am a little confused still with the part about representational dynamic of community politics. The two definitions seem so definitive. The descriptions also seem critical, like either the person representing a group is a martyr or a user. Both seem manipulative. Are there other ways of defining the ways that groups gain representation?

2) In the reading a politically coherent community is described as forming in a response to a collective mode of oppression. Is that the only way a politically coherent community can be formed? I think I am missing what it means to be politically coherent. For example I think that an environmental conservation community could be formed due to precautionary measures. Ansel Adams wasn’t fighting global warming when he advocated for national parks, he was just trying to protect areas of wilderness. Can a politically coherent community be precautionary?


3) What is a moral economy of capitalism? There is a really long sentence with very complex words talking about conservative arguments and  liberal reform. Honestly I get scared when ever politics begin to play a part in doing good because politics are connected to larger immovable machines. When doing good becomes political I see it shut down under the weight of competing parties.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Research- Andrew Moore

My first year at calarts, I was unfortunately raveled in a title 9 investigation revolving sexual misconduct. While I was not a involved directly, I was a bystander and very good friend to the person who started the investigation. I was asked by the affected person to be interviewed for evidence. My experience in the interview room with the investigator was anything but reassuring. I was asked to give my side of the story, but I was pushed by questions asked by the investigator that were geared towards finding the attacker innocent. I used to have trust in the government ability to handle situations like this justly, but I was disappointed to see that the disgusting stories that I've heard about victim blaming and non-fiction. The fact that it was unraveling itself before my eyes was very surprising. Unfortunately the person stayed in the dorms on campus through all of this and at the end of the year there was an even more dramatic event involving the same person and another gir...
Post a Comment
Read more

Prison system effect on communities of color/ Connection to slavery

Although the United States has made some progress, it remains a substantially racially segregated nation residentially. And, the country stays very economically segregated as well. It is not surprising that poor people of color have been incarcerated disproportionately during the massive increase in imprisonment that has occurred in the nation since the early 1980s. It is from poor communities of color that a very large number of felons are removed, and to these same neighborhoods that they return when their sentences end. This population churning has been called “coercive mobility” by criminologists. Although it is the intent of legislatures, judges, police, and prosecutors to protect citizens and communities, there is reason to believe that coercive mobility has the unintended consequence of actually increasing crime and victimization. There is overrepresentation of minority group members among those engaging in crime, but even after this is taken into account, people of color a...
Post a Comment
Read more

What a Riot!

What strategies did she employ in her process of making in play with the youth? Some of the strategies Mady Schutzman employed in her process of making a play with the youth were, utilizing the Joker System, presenting exercises to create a “safe” space by opening the floor and space to the youth to speak, reflect, and share their stories. What approaches resonated with you? Many of the approaches that were used were very intriguing and interesting, but there was one approach that resonated with me. Particularly, the questions that came out of one of the approaches. In the vein of the Joker System, it was designed to ,”promote social inquiry and personal agency by asking questions (How do I know what I know? Who authored the historical narratives we reiterate? Are those stories relevant to me and my community? Who do they privilege and who do they marginalize?” Mandy shared. These questions resonated with me because they are questions I have been asking myself this...
Post a Comment
Read more